|
Like
Sue Miller's GOOD MOTHER and Rosellen Brown's BEFORE AND AFTER,
this new novel by Jane Hamilton aspires to combine a melodramatic
soap-opera plot with highly tuned literary writing, the pacing of
a thriller with the psychological detail of a Bildungsroman....[t]he results are something of a mixed
bag:
bizarrely clumsy and contrived scenes combined with highly moving
moments of exceptional emotional clarity, and a motley cast of
characters, ranging from the stereotyped to the dexterously well
drawn....[The] difficulties are, to some degree, offset by the
strengths of Ms. Hamilton's writing: her eye for the emotional
detail, her expert manipulation of point of view, her ability to
show us Alice's fears and delusions, her need for penance and her
yearning for redemption. The reader only hopes that Ms. Hamilton's
next book will better showcase her considerable gifts."
-- Michiko Kakutani
|